Recent research published in Nature Food has created a new method for evaluating how processed grocery items really are. A comprehensive study analyzed over 50,000 products from three major U.S. retailers (Whole Foods, Walmart, and Target) and found that highly processed foods dominate shelf space across all stores. However, Whole Foods offered slightly more minimally processed options than Walmart and Target.
This prevalence of ultra-processed foods creates what researchers describe as an "illusion of choice" for consumers. Despite different branding and packaging, most ultra-processed products share similar characteristics: high levels of sugar, salt, and oils, plus various additives that enhance flavor, appearance, and shelf life while potentially reducing nutritional value.
Health concerns associated with ultra-processed food consumption include increased risks of obesity, type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. However, the specific health impacts vary by food category. A 2024 Harvard study found that while sugary drinks and processed meats were linked to higher cardiovascular disease risk, certain ultra-processed breads, cereals, and dairy products showed different patterns.
The new FPro scoring system developed by the researchers improves upon the previous NOVA classification by recognizing that food processing exists on a spectrum rather than in distinct categories. This system analyzes nutrient profiles to estimate processing levels, with researchers now working to predict specific industrial processes foods undergo.
Affordability creates additional challenges. The study found that ultra-processed foods typically cost about half as much as minimally processed alternatives. This price difference creates nutritional inequalities that disproportionately affect lower-income populations.
Nutrition experts recommend a simple approach for consumers: shop the store perimeter, where fresher, less processed options like produce, fish, and dairy are typically located. Remember that "less processed" doesn't automatically mean "healthy" - a cookie remains a treat regardless of how it's processed.
About the authors
Read more at Keith & Kathy's Corner
