New research identifies garlic, allspice, and other natural compounds with potent activity against dormant bacteria.
Researchers have identified several essential oils that show remarkable effectiveness against treatment-resistant forms of the bacteria that cause Lyme disease, potentially opening new avenues for addressing one of the most challenging aspects of this increasingly common illness.
The study, conducted by researchers including scientists from Johns Hopkins University and published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal, tested 35 essential oils against Borrelia burgdorferi, the spirochetal bacteria responsible for Lyme disease. The research focused specifically on dormant, non-growing forms of the bacteria that current antibiotics struggle to eliminate.
The Challenge of Persistent Lyme Disease
Lyme disease affects approximately 300,000 Americans annually, making it the most common vector-borne illness in the United States. While most patients respond well to standard antibiotic treatment with doxycycline, amoxicillin, or cefuroxime, about 36 percent continue experiencing symptoms, including fatigue, joint pain, and neuropsychiatric issues, six months after completing therapy.
This condition, known as post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome (PTLDS), has puzzled medical professionals for years. One theory suggests that some bacteria enter a dormant state called "persisters" that allows them to survive standard antibiotic treatment, potentially leading to ongoing infection.
Breakthrough Findings
The research team discovered that 10 essential oils demonstrated significant activity against these dormant bacterial forms at concentrations as low as 0.1 percent. The most promising candidates included:
Garlic (Allium sativum) - The standout performer, eliminating bacterial growth even at 0.05 percent concentration
Allspice (Pimenta officinalis) - showed strong activity with complete sterilization at 0.1 percent
Myrrh (Commiphora myrrha) - Traditional medicine with proven antibacterial properties
Palmarosa (Cymbopogon martini) - Demonstrated consistent effectiveness across testing
Cumin (Cuminum cyminum) - Common spice with unexpected potency
The study also identified cinnamaldehyde, the active component in cinnamon bark essential oil, as particularly effective against both growing and dormant bacteria. This compound showed activity against replicating bacteria at concentrations as low as 0.2 micrograms per milliliter.
Laboratory Testing Methods
Researchers used seven-day-old bacterial cultures that had entered a stationary phase, during which the bacteria form dormant persisters naturally resistant to conventional antibiotics. These cultures were treated with various concentrations of essential oils for seven days, then assessed using fluorescent microscopy to determine bacterial viability.
To confirm their findings, scientists conducted subculture experiments, washing treated bacteria and placing them in fresh growth medium for 21 days to see if any organisms would regrow. The most effective treatments showed no bacterial regrowth, indicating complete sterilization.
Compared to Current Treatments
When tested against standard Lyme antibiotics, the essential oils significantly outperformed conventional treatments. While doxycycline, the most commonly prescribed Lyme antibiotic, left approximately 66 percent of bacteria viable after treatment, garlic essential oil at similar concentrations eliminated all detectable organisms.
Even daptomycin, an expensive intravenous antibiotic chosen explicitly for its anti-persister activity, was less effective than several of the essential oils tested. These natural compounds may work through different mechanisms than current antibiotics.
Historical Context and Traditional Use
Many of the effective essential oils have long histories as antimicrobial agents. Garlic has been recognized for its antibacterial properties since ancient times, with Louis Pasteur documenting its activity in 1858. Myrrh has served as an antiseptic since antiquity and remains used in modern toothpastes and topical applications.
Allspice functions as both a flavoring agent and natural preservative in food processing, while traditional Chinese medicine has employed Litsea cubeba for bacterial infections for centuries. These historical uses lend credibility to the laboratory findings.
Chemical Analysis
The researchers analyzed the chemical composition of the most active essential oils using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Garlic oil's primary active compounds included diallyl disulfide and related sulfur compounds, while allspice derived its potency mainly from eugenol, comprising 82 percent of the oil's content.
Myrrh's activity appeared linked to compounds like curzerene and furanoeudesma-1,3-diene, though some previously identified antimicrobial components were not detected in the tested samples.
Limitations and Future Research
While these laboratory results appear promising, researchers emphasize that in vitro effectiveness does not guarantee success in living organisms. The essential oils must still undergo extensive testing to determine their safety, proper dosing, and effectiveness in animal models before any human trials can begin.
The study authors plan to identify and isolate the specific active compounds within each essential oil, test combinations of different oils or oils with conventional antibiotics, and conduct pharmacokinetic studies to understand how these compounds behave in living systems.
Safety considerations remain paramount, as some essential oil components can be toxic at higher concentrations or when administered improperly. For instance, while cinnamaldehyde appears relatively safe when consumed orally, its intravenous toxicity profile requires careful evaluation.
Implications for Treatment
If future studies confirm the safety and effectiveness of these compounds in animal models and eventually human trials, they could represent a significant advancement in Lyme disease treatment. The ability to target dormant bacterial forms could prevent the development of PTLDS and improve outcomes for patients with treatment-resistant infections.
The research also suggests that combination therapies using both conventional antibiotics and essential oil components might prove more effective than either approach alone, as different compounds appear to target bacteria through distinct mechanisms.
Looking Forward
The essential oil research represents part of a broader effort to develop more effective treatments for persistent bacterial infections. Similar approaches are being investigated for other conditions, including tuberculosis, where dormant bacteria also pose treatment challenges.
However, patients and healthcare providers should not interpret these preliminary findings as recommendations for self-treatment. Essential oils can interact with medications, cause allergic reactions, and may be harmful if misused. Any potential therapeutic applications require rigorous clinical testing and regulatory approval.
The study adds to growing evidence that natural compounds may offer untapped potential for addressing antibiotic-resistant infections, but translating laboratory discoveries into safe, effective treatments remains a complex process requiring years of additional research.
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered medical advice. The research described involves laboratory studies only and has not been tested in humans. Do not attempt to self-treat Lyme disease or any other medical condition with essential oils or other unproven remedies. Always consult with qualified healthcare professionals for proper diagnosis and treatment of medical conditions. Essential oils can be toxic and may interact with medications. Never discontinue prescribed medications without consulting your healthcare provider.
Reference: Feng, J., Shi, W., Miklossy, J., Tauxe, G. M., McMeniman, C. J., & Zhang, Y. (2018). Identification of Essential Oils with Strong Activity against Stationary Phase Borrelia burgdorferi. Antibiotics, 7(4), 89. PMCID: PMC6316231, PMID: 30332754.
About the authors
Read more at Keith & Kathy's Corner
