As a nutritionist and nutritional biochemist, I've seen my fair share of dietary trends come and go. The latest one making waves on social media has caught my attention—and not necessarily for good reasons. TikToker William Kim has gained millions of views by showcasing what internet users have dubbed "human kibble"—a mixture of 19 finely chopped ingredients combined into one repetitive meal that he claims to eat daily.
Kim's concoction includes a medley of vegetables, chicken breast, tofu, grains, and legumes, all prepared in bulk and consumed consistently. While the approach has garnered praise from some viewers who appreciate its simplicity, it's also drawn comparisons to actual pet food—a comparison that, frankly, isn't far off the mark.
Understanding the Appeal
I can understand why this method might appeal to specific individuals. The batch-cooking approach eliminates decision fatigue and can ensure consistent intake of various nutrients. When ingredients are finely chopped and mixed together, it makes vegetables more palatable for those who typically struggle with consuming enough vegetables. The high fiber content and diverse nutrient profile could theoretically support good health.
For people overwhelmed by meal planning or those who view eating as purely a means to fuel their bodies, this systematic approach might seem like an efficient solution. The time savings and reduced cognitive load around food choices are undeniable benefits.
Why I Can't Recommend This Approach
However, as someone who has spent years studying nutrition and its impact on human health, I have several significant concerns about this trend:
Nutritional Inadequacy Risks: While the mix appears diverse, eating the same combination daily almost guarantees dietary gaps. Our bodies require a rotating variety of nutrients, and even the most well-intentioned blend cannot capture the full spectrum of what we need from food. Seasonal variations in produce, different preparation methods, and varied food combinations all contribute to optimal nutrition in ways that a single recipe cannot replicate.
Metabolic Monotony: Our digestive systems and metabolism benefit from variety. Consuming identical meals repeatedly can lead to adaptive responses where our bodies become less efficient at extracting specific nutrients.
Psychological and Social Implications: Food serves purposes far beyond mere nutrition. It's central to cultural practices, social bonding, emotional comfort, and sensory pleasure. Reducing eating to such a mechanical process strips away these fundamental human experiences. This approach can contribute to an unhealthy relationship with food. It may increase the risk of developing rigid eating patterns or disordered eating behaviors.
Micronutrient Concerns: Despite appearing comprehensive, any single food combination will have inherent limitations. Certain nutrients require specific food pairings for optimal absorption, while others may be over-represented. The lack of rotation means missing out on beneficial compounds found in foods not included in the mix.
Sustainability Issues: Most people cannot maintain such a restrictive approach long-term. When individuals inevitably crave variety or social eating experiences, they may feel as though they've "failed," leading to feelings of guilt or abandonment of healthy eating altogether.
A Balanced Perspective
While I appreciate the efficiency this method offers, it represents a fundamental misunderstanding of how nutrition works best in our lives. Optimal health comes not just from meeting nutrient targets but from maintaining a positive and flexible relationship with food that supports both physical and mental well-being.
Instead of "human kibble," I recommend embracing meal prep strategies that maintain variety—perhaps preparing several different healthy options to rotate throughout the week. This approach captures many of the time-saving benefits while preserving the joy, cultural significance, and nutritional diversity that food is meant to provide.
Remember, we are complex beings with complex needs. Our approach to nutrition should reflect that complexity rather than reducing us to the level of pets eating from a bowl.
Dr. Kathryn Munoz is a nutritionist and nutritional biochemist and is the CEO of 4VitaHealth, an supplement company focussed on brain optimization and education.
more from the author
